See our Outsourcing Provider Directory here

An Attorney Outlines Some Outsourcing Challenges for Manufacturers

On January 24, an underground fire gutted a New York City subway signal relay room that transmitted information about train positions. Metropolitan Transportation Authority officials told the New York Times they would need six to nine months to restore regular service to two subway lines. The reason: few people today know how to repair the original 1930’s equipment.

Adam Chernichaw, an attorney with White & Case in New York, uses that recent example to point out one of the challenges manufacturers face when they outsource: they often lose employees who have the experience and knowledge to run their specialized systems to the supplier. “Many manufacturers have made large capital expenditures for specialized equipment that go back decades. What happens when something breaks?” asks the attorney, who rides the affected subway lines.

The outsourcing challenge becomes compounded if that aged equipment uses legacy software whose authors have long since disappeared, gone out of business, or been acquired.

First, the attorney suggests manufacturers think carefully about sending key employees who have specialized knowledge of the production systems to the supplier. “Sometimes it’s best not to outsource everybody,” he says. “Someone on the shop floor or in the head office has to know what’s up.”

The Best Remedy: Document Everything

Regardless of who goes and who stays, Chernichaw advises manufacturers to make sure “everything is well-documented.” In addition to equipment and process operations manuals, Chernichaw recommends putting in the outsourcing contract that the manufacturer owns any new code the supplier produces for its equipment. This is especially important if the manufacturer has kept key employees to run the shop who now need to understand and use the new code.

How Useful Are Penalties?

Another outsourcing challenge is how to outsource the manufacturing process if the process includes a “secret sauce.” What if the supplier has employees who work with several buyers, any one of whom could benefit from knowing that secret recipe? This can become a problem. “The manufacturer has to figure out a way to protect the confidentiality of its manufacturing trade secrets,” he says.

For example, industry lore says only a handful of people at Coca-Cola know the entire recipe for its syrups. He suggests manufacturers develop ways “to insulate” this knowledge from the outsourcer to protect their trade secrets.

The outsourcing contract will probably have penalties if the supplier violates this trust, but “even if the contract has significant penalties, that may not make up for loss of a company’s secrets,” points out the lawyer.

Manufacturers whose distribution chain is reliant on the outsourced service also face significant risks. For example, if the infrastructure in the outsourcer’s data center goes out, there will be ripples throughout the supply chain. “Will liquidated damages or service credits in the outsourcing contract make up for the lost profits?” the lawyer asks rhetorically.

In today’s competitive environment, outsourcing is not an option but a necessity for manufacturers. Thinking about these sandbars in advance can make the sailing easier.

Get 3 Free Quotes Logo

  • Save 70%
  • Unrivaled expertise
  • Verified leading firms
  • Transparent, safe, secure

Get Started

Small Teams Call Logo

Start your Outsourcing Journey in 15 seconds.

Get Started

Enterprise & Large
Teams Call
Logo

Explore with an Enterprise Expert

  • Independent
  • Trusted
  • Transparent
Outsourcing

Dive into “Outsourcing”

A Guide to … Selecting the Correct Business Unit … Negotiating the Contract … Maintaining Control of the Process

Order now

Outsourcing Articles

Start your
outsourcing
journey here

"*" indicates required fields

Start your outsourcing journey.

Book a call with an outsourcing expert now

This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.

"*" indicates required fields

This guide will walk you through some areas most important when outsourcing, such as
  • Identifying Your Outsourcing Needs Intelligently
  • Research & Selection
  • The Bidding Process
  • Contracts & Agreements
  • Implementation & Onboarding
  • Ongoing Management
  • Evaluating Success
  • Additional Resources

Book a call with an outsourcing expert now

This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.

"*" indicates required fields

Become an OC Partner
This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.

"*" indicates required fields

Media Inquiries for OC
This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.

"*" indicates required fields

Subscribe to our Newsletter
This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.

"*" indicates required fields

Submit Press Release
Accepted file types: pdf, doc, docx, Max. file size: 8 MB.
This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.

"*" indicates required fields

Submit an Article
Accepted file types: pdf, doc, docx, Max. file size: 8 MB.
This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.

"*" indicates required fields

Request Ben Trowbridge as a Keynote Speaker
This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.

Go to standard quote

Exclusive Enterprise Assistance

  • Independent
  • Trusted
  • Transparent

Offshore staffing solutions for enterprise. Independent expertise, advice & implementation

  • 200+ Firms, Global Reach
  • Offshore, Nearshore, Onshore, Rightshore
  • Managed Request for Proposal (RFP)
  • Assisted Procurement Processes
  • Vendor Management
  • Unique Build Operate Transfer model
  • Captive & Shared Services
  • Champion-Challenger
  • Multi-site, multi-vendor, multi-source
  • Managed Solutions

For Enterprise and large teams only

  • Book 20-minute consult, obligation free

You will get:

  • Needs Analysis & Report
  • Salary Guidance & Indicative Pricing
  • Process Map

Only takes 1 minute to complete the form

Get Started

Not an enterprise?

Go to standard quote